Ellen Isaacs My smiling face
Topics
My Home Page
Professional Interests

Personal Interests

Photography
Travel
Reading
  Books read in 2006
  Books read in 2005
  Books read in 2004
  Books read in 2003
  Books read in 2002
  Books read in 2001
  Books read in 2000
  Books read in 1999
    Poisonwood Bible
    The Loop
    War & Remembrance
    Winds of War
    Angela's Ashes
    Henry VIII
    Pilot's Wife
    Replay
    Cold Mountain
    Comeback Choir
    Memoirs of a Geisha
    Where the Heart Is
    Widow For One Year
    Bucking the Sun
    Accidental Empires
    Midwives
  Books read in 1998
  Books read in 1997
  Books read in 1996
  Books read in 1995
  Books read in 1994
  Books read in 1993
  Books read in 1992
  Books read in 1991
  Books read in 1990
  Books read in 1989
  Books read in 1988
link to Amazon Singing in the Comeback Choir
By Bebe Moore Campbell
[Buy this book]

Review by Ellen Isaacs

Rating: 0
-4 -3 -2 -1   0 +1 +2 +3 +4

The story is about Maxine, a black woman executive producer of a TV talk show who has a great life on the surface but is dealing with problems on several fronts. Her show is in danger of being cancelled. The grandmother who raised her, a famous singer from an earlier generation, has lost hope after she had a stroke. And she's still trying to forgive her otherwise wonderful husband Satchel for cheating on her.

This book disappointed me. When I read Campbell's Your Blues Ain't Like Mine, I became a fan of her ability to bring to life many and varied characters, drawing out their different points of view. I was especially impressed with the way she helped you to understand the most unsympathetic of characters. In this book, and to a lesser degree her last one, Brothers and Sisters, the characters seem one-dimensional and flat. The story is fairly predictable and, when everything works out just grand in the end, formulaic and unbelievable. The dialog is stiff, even telegraphic, especially the phone calls between Maxine and Satchel when Maxine is visiting her grandmother. The book was easy to breeze through, but in the end, it wasn't very satisfying.

Previous
  (Cold Mountain)
Next
  (Memoirs of a Geisha)

© 2005 Ellen Isaacs