Ellen Isaacs My smiling face
Topics
My Home Page
Professional Interests

Personal Interests

Photography
Travel
Reading
  Books read in 2006
  Books read in 2005
  Books read in 2004
  Books read in 2003
  Books read in 2002
  Books read in 2001
  Books read in 2000
  Books read in 1999
    Poisonwood Bible
    The Loop
    War & Remembrance
    Winds of War
    Angela's Ashes
    Henry VIII
    Pilot's Wife
    Replay
    Cold Mountain
    Comeback Choir
    Memoirs of a Geisha
    Where the Heart Is
    Widow For One Year
    Bucking the Sun
    Accidental Empires
    Midwives
  Books read in 1998
  Books read in 1997
  Books read in 1996
  Books read in 1995
  Books read in 1994
  Books read in 1993
  Books read in 1992
  Books read in 1991
  Books read in 1990
  Books read in 1989
  Books read in 1988
link to Amazon Midwives
By Chris Bohjalian
[Buy this book]

Review by Ellen Isaacs

Rating: +3
-4 -3 -2 -1   0 +1 +2 +3 +4

This book is centered around a midwife who carries out a make-shift C-section to save a baby after the mother dies during childbirth. The question is whether the mother really did die beforehand, as the midwife perceived, or whether the C-section caused the death. The midwife is taken to trial and shunned by much of this small New England community, except for her core friends and allies. The book is the story of this midwife's trial and how it affects her family.

When I first started this book, I wondered whether a politically correct view of midwives would hold my interest. I already believe midwives are a perfectly legitimate alternative to doctors, so I didn't think I'd be compelled by the controversy. Within a few chapters, though, I was drawn in not just by the story, but by the voice of its narrator. The story is told from the perspective of the midwife's 14-year-old daughter, who is writing this as a grown woman.

The book moves along at a steady pace, gradually disclosing the details of the unfortunate birth as the trial unfolds. But it was not so much the outcome of the trial that made me want to turn the pages. Instead, it was the daughter's interpretation of the events, how it affected her development, and how she came to understand her mother's motivations that intrigued me through to the very end. I was even more interested when I realized part-way through that the author (Chris Bohjalian) is a man. I was impressed by how well he captured the workings of a teenage girl's mind.

This is a good story, well told.

Previous
  (Accidental Empires)

© 2005 Ellen Isaacs