Ellen Isaacs My smiling face
Topics
My Home Page
Professional Interests

Personal Interests

Photography
Travel
Reading
  Books read in 2006
  Books read in 2005
  Books read in 2004
  Books read in 2003
  Books read in 2002
  Books read in 2001
  Books read in 2000
    Here On Earth
    Monk & Riddle
    Brothers of Gwynedd
    Home Waters
    Daughter of Fortune
    Charming Billy
    Tuesdays with Morrie
    For Love
    Web Usability
    Good Mother
    While I Was Gone
    Book of Ruth
    America Calling
    River Cross My Heart
    East of Mountains
    Map of the World
    All the Pretty Horses
    Aztec
    Night of Many Dreams
    Inmates .. Asylum
    Women of the Silk
    Sword of Truth
    Nudist on Late Shift
  Books read in 1999
  Books read in 1998
  Books read in 1997
  Books read in 1996
  Books read in 1995
  Books read in 1994
  Books read in 1993
  Books read in 1992
  Books read in 1991
  Books read in 1990
  Books read in 1989
  Books read in 1988
link to Amazon Home Waters
By Joseph Monninger
[Buy this book]

Review by Ellen Isaacs

Rating: +2
-4 -3 -2 -1   0 +1 +2 +3 +4

Home Waters is a charming story about a fly fisherman and his dog. It is Monninger's memoir and tribute to his dog, Nellie, an eleven-year-old Golden Retriever, who he has recently learned has cancer. He decides to take a road trip from his home in New Hampshire to visit some of his favorite fishing spots in Wyoming, Idaho, and Montana. Monninger takes the reader along for the ride, describing the details of his fishing trips — where he sets up, which type of bait he uses, how he adjusts his technique to the circumstances — and how Nellie accompanies him in all he does — how she sniffs at each stick and stone as she explores a new area, how she snuggles into his sleeping bag on cold nights, how she taught herself to dive under water after him. As he makes his way through the trip, he reminisces about earlier fishing trips and other experiences he and Nellie have shared.

I loved the tone of this book. Monninger has a pleasant, matter-of-fact way of telling a story. I especially liked how he conveyed his simple love and respect for Nellie just in the way he interacted with her and in his reports of their conversations: "I told Nellie we were done for the night. She seemed grateful." Or, "I told her she was a good dog." When Nellie encountered a harvested potato field, she gave her best shot at retrieving the hundreds of potatoes left on the ground, only to be defeated by the magnitude of the task. Monninger says, "I consoled her on the walk back to the truck, telling her we all have such days, then fed and watered her. I told her to lay down on her dog bed and she did." After he returns to his hotel: "When I unhooked Nellie's leash inside the room, she put her nose on the edge of the bed, asking permission to get up. I told her to go ahead, but not to hog the whole thing. She curled at the foot of the bed, tail to nose. I sat besider her and gave her a rub. In a little while she began to snore. I read for awhile, then turned out the light." I especially related to his dilemma when he went fishing at Yellowstone. "The hard part was explaining to Nellie it is against park regulations to take a dog into the back country.... Nellie wasn't pleased with it... and when I locked her in the back of the truck, she whined to come with me. I was firm with her and caved only enough to give her a biscuit." I've never been fly fishing, but I enjoyed Monninger's equally droll explanations of how it works, the strategy (and luck) that goes into it. I think I now understood why "the one that got away" haunts every fisherman.

Previous
  (Brothers of Gwynedd)
Next
  (Daughter of Fortune)

© 2005 Ellen Isaacs