Ellen Isaacs My smiling face
Topics
My Home Page
Professional Interests

Personal Interests

Photography
Travel
Reading
  Books read in 2006
  Books read in 2005
  Books read in 2004
  Books read in 2003
  Books read in 2002
  Books read in 2001
  Books read in 2000
    Here On Earth
    Monk & Riddle
    Brothers of Gwynedd
    Home Waters
    Daughter of Fortune
    Charming Billy
    Tuesdays with Morrie
    For Love
    Web Usability
    Good Mother
    While I Was Gone
    Book of Ruth
    America Calling
    River Cross My Heart
    East of Mountains
    Map of the World
    All the Pretty Horses
    Aztec
    Night of Many Dreams
    Inmates .. Asylum
    Women of the Silk
    Sword of Truth
    Nudist on Late Shift
  Books read in 1999
  Books read in 1998
  Books read in 1997
  Books read in 1996
  Books read in 1995
  Books read in 1994
  Books read in 1993
  Books read in 1992
  Books read in 1991
  Books read in 1990
  Books read in 1989
  Books read in 1988
link to Amazon All the Pretty Horses
By Cormac McCarthy
[Buy this book]

Review by Ellen Isaacs

Rating: +1
-4 -3 -2 -1   0 +1 +2 +3 +4

All the Pretty Horses is the story of John Grady Cole and his friend Lacey Rawlins, two teenage boys who leave home in southern Texas and cross into Mexico on horseback, seeking adulthood and independence. They find it through a series of adventures that take them deep into Mexico and back again. Skilled with horses, they wind up working at a horse ranch owned by a wealthy family. Cole falls in love with the daughter, but despite the respect he's earned from her father, the family intervenes, and Cole is arrested and put in jail. On his way back to freedom, he has to fight for his life, his love, his friendships, and his horse.

This book is more about mood and character than it is about plot. Despite all of Cole & Rawlins' adventures, the book is fairly slow moving. McCarthy writes beautifully, paying attention to the details that make up the simple action of putting a saddle on a horse, for example, or lighting up a cigarette. At times I found this relaxing, but other times it made me restless. I can see why this book received such praise, since the writing does create such a peaceful atmosphere even when talking about violent events. However, it didn't work for me that well. I ended up feeling distant from the events and the people in the story, never understanding their motivations or reactions to events. I suppose I enjoyed the read, but I didn't especially look forward to getting back to it each evening.

This book is the first in what's called the Border Trilogy, including The Crossing, and Cities of the Plain. However, I happened to have listened to part of The Crossing on audio tape a few years ago, and it didn't involve any of the same characters, so perhaps it's series only in that it takes place in the same region at about the same time and has a similar mood. On the other hand, Cities of the Plain appears to involve John Grady Cole, or perhaps his son or grandson, so I'm not sure what to make of calling this a trilogy.

Previous
  (Map of the World)
Next
  (Aztec)

© 2005 Ellen Isaacs