Ellen Isaacs My smiling face
Topics
My Home Page
Professional Interests

Personal Interests

Photography
Travel
Reading
  Books read in 2006
  Books read in 2005
  Books read in 2004
  Books read in 2003
  Books read in 2002
  Books read in 2001
    Art of Innovation
    Niccolo Rising
    First Break Rules
    Don't Make Me Think
    Bowling Alone
    Jewel
  Books read in 2000
  Books read in 1999
  Books read in 1998
  Books read in 1997
  Books read in 1996
  Books read in 1995
  Books read in 1994
  Books read in 1993
  Books read in 1992
  Books read in 1991
  Books read in 1990
  Books read in 1989
  Books read in 1988
link to Amazon Jewel
By AUTHOR
[Buy this book]

Review by Ellen Isaacs

Rating: +2
-4 -3 -2 -1   0 +1 +2 +3 +4

In 1943 in Mississippi, Jewel Hilburn gives birth to a child with Down's Syndrome, changing the course of her and her family's life. Jewel, who spent part of her childhood in an orphanage, is determined not to put Brenda Kay in an institution, even though she and the doctors know relatively little about how to take care of her. The cost is that she has little energy left for her husband Leston and her five other children. Eventually, she sees an article in Reader's Digest of a school in Los Angeles for children like Brenda Kay, and she is determined to overcome Leston's objections to moving to a place so far and different from their home. When they finally move, Jewel becomes involved in the school, while the rest of the family grows up, building new lives in this very different world. By the end, Jewel and Leston reconcile their choices and how their lives have been affected by Brenda Kay.

This book could have been one of those formula "triumph over adversity" stories that are frequently made into Hollywood movies. Instead, I found this book to be a rich character study that gave a realistic portrait of how people make do when faced with hardship. I'm no expert on Down's Syndrome, but I did spend a summer as a counselor for kids with Down's, and the characterization of Brenda Kay's behavior rang true to me. So did the way Jewel gradually adjusted her expectations to match Brenda Kay's abilities, so that she could take great joy in each small step, just as you would with any child. I found it especially interesting to see how Jewel coped at a time when there was less support for people with this syndrome, at a time when the syndrome was actually called Mongoloid Idiocy. Lott's lovely writing style and insightful but understated tone enhance the story. Jewel is an enjoyable and worthwile book to read.

Previous
  (Bowling Alone)
Next
  (Books read in 2001)

© 2005 Ellen Isaacs